Five Chinese Nationals Charged in Massive Apple Fraud Scheme That Used Counterfeit iPhones and iPads to Steal Millions
Five Chinese nationals were charged in Los Angeles in May 2024 in a multi-year scheme that used more than 16,000 counterfeit iPhones and iPads to obtain genuine replacements, causing at least $12.3 million in losses to Apple.
- Defendants named: Yang Song (alleged ringleader), Junwei Jiang, Zhengxuan Hu, Yushan Lin and Shuyi Xing.
- Scale of returns: Prosecutors say more than 16,000 counterfeit Apple devices were fraudulently returned or attempted returns.
- Estimated loss: At least $12.3 million in losses to Apple; prosecutors say the actual loss may be higher.
- Federal charges: Conspiracy, wire and mail fraud, aggravated identity theft, and trafficking in counterfeit goods; indictment unsealed after May 2024 arrests.
How the alleged scheme worked
Prosecutors allege the group built a trans-Pacific operation that exploited Apple’s customer-service and return policies. Members obtained forged or counterfeit Apple devices, then returned those fake products to Apple retail stores and service channels as if they were broken, genuine devices. Under Apple’s replacement rules, the company issued authentic replacement devices to customers. The defendants allegedly collected those genuine replacements, shipped them overseas — mainly to China — and sold them for profit. (Source: IRS Criminal Investigation press release on device-return scheme)
Logistics, scope and organization
Investigators say the operation used organized methods and logistical networks to move high-value electronics out of the United States. The alleged enterprise ran for several years and involved more than 16,000 returns — far larger than isolated retail fraud. Evidence cited in the indictment includes return records, shipment logs, retail surveillance footage and electronic records. (Source: IRS Criminal Investigation device-return release)
Scope, evidence and arrests
The indictment filed in federal court in Los Angeles charges the defendants with an array of federal counts, including:
- Conspiracy to commit wire and mail fraud
- One count of aggravated identity theft
- Seven counts of wire fraud and 12 counts of mail fraud
- One count of conspiracy to traffic in counterfeit goods
Arrests were carried out in May 2024 and the indictment was unsealed shortly after. United States Attorney Martin Estrada said the defendants “are accused of taking advantage of Apple’s customer-service policies to steal more than $12 million in merchandise,” emphasizing the office’s commitment to pursuing large-scale fraud. (Source: IRS Criminal Investigation statement)
“They are accused of taking advantage of Apple’s customer-service policies to steal more than $12 million in merchandise.”
— United States Attorney Martin Estrada
Related schemes and broader patterns
Federal investigators say the device-return scheme fits into a wider pattern of fraud targeting U.S. tech supply chains. In related cases, other Chinese nationals pleaded guilty in a separate gift-card purchase-and-export scheme that used stolen or illicit gift cards to buy Apple devices in the U.S., then exported those products to China and Hong Kong for resale. Prosecutors noted opportunistic targeting of states with no sales tax to maximize margins. (Source: IRS Criminal Investigation release on related guilty pleas)
Legal process and what’s next
The defendants were arraigned in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles after the indictment was unsealed. The case will progress through the federal court system, where prosecutors must prove the alleged conspiracy and fraud beyond a reasonable doubt. Defense attorneys may challenge evidence, argue mistaken identity, or raise other defenses. As of public filings in May 2024, the device-return case defendants were charged and arrested; public records do not confirm guilty pleas in this specific indictment. (Sources: IRS device-return release, IRS guilty-pleas release)
Implications for Los Angeles
Economic impact: The operation ran out of the Los Angeles area and leveraged local retail stores and shipping networks. Large-scale fraud can raise costs for retailers and manufacturers and may prompt Apple and other retailers to tighten return policies or increase inspections, potentially affecting local shoppers’ service experience. (Source: IRS press release)
Political consequences: Local leaders and law enforcement may use the case to advocate for tougher enforcement at ports, stricter oversight of e-commerce and parcel shipping, and increased federal-local coordination to monitor similar schemes.
Social effects: Retail workers and managers could face greater scrutiny and added duties to confirm returns. Customers may see longer wait times or stricter proof-of-purchase rules. Communities with many immigrant residents will likely watch how investigations and arrests are handled to ensure fair treatment and due process.
Practical applications for residents and businesses
- Keep receipts and serial numbers for device purchases; expect retailers to require more proof when exchanging electronics.
- Local businesses should review loss-prevention practices and train staff to spot counterfeit devices and suspicious return patterns.
- Residents who suspect fraud or notice unusual shipping activity are encouraged to report tips to local law enforcement or federal agencies involved in the investigation.
Reporting and sources
This report draws on U.S. Department of the Treasury / IRS Criminal Investigation press releases and public court filings detailing the indictment, arrests and related investigations. For full details, see the IRS Criminal Investigation news releases:
